Latest review
First review round: 12.3 weeks. Overall rating: 2 (moderate).
Outcome: Rejected.
Motivation:
The manuscript was reviewed by 3 reviewers. One reviewer said that the overall quality of the paper cannot be judged based on a single review and wrote lots of comments, which I revised then thoughtfully. When the revised manuscript was sent to this reviewer again, he/she recommended a rejection. The other reviewer recommended a rejection straight at the beginning with incomprehensible reasons, e.g., the introduction is too short and the conclusions are too long.
