Latest review
First review round: 10.0 weeks. Overall rating: 5 (excellent).
Outcome: Accepted.
Motivation:
We received a major revision and then the resubmission was accepted by the editor. We heard from 2 reviewers and their comments and suggestions were all spot-on, though some are tough to address. We even got an extension for resubmission from the assisting editors. The process was smooth and rigorous. The requirement of formatting was quite different than other journals in the field though.