Reviews for "Urban Studies"

Journal title	Average duration			Review reports (1^st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page)	1^st rev. rnd	Tot. handling	Im. rejection	Number	Quality	Overall rating	Outcome
Urban Studies	15.1 weeks	21.9 weeks	n/a	2	3 (good)	4 (very good)	Accepted
Urban Studies	Motivation: Excellent work by the editor who helped us navigate one difficult reviewer.
Urban Studies	18.1 weeks	42.6 weeks	n/a	3	4 (very good)	1 (bad)	Rejected
Urban Studies	Motivation: My article was rejected after two review rounds. However, I already convinced two of my three reviewers after the first round. In addition, it is my believe that the editor could have known before sending my paper back to the last reviewer that my changes would not satisfy this reviewer and he should have decided to either accept or reject my paper immediately after I resubmitted the second time. Lastly, the quality of some of the arguments of that final revision was very low.