Dur. 1st rev. rnd
Tot. handling time
Imm. rejection time
Num. rev. reports
Report quality
Overall rating
Outcome
Year
24.6 weeks
24.6 weeks
n/a
0 reports
n/a
Rejected
2022
Motivation:
Half a year after the initial submission, the editor notified me that he had decided to reject the paper based on the reviewers' comments. However, the editor did not provide me with any insight into the reviewers' comments, despite my request that they be forwarded to me.
In this way, it appears that the editorial board of Scientia Iranica Journal is only using the reviewers' efforts to support the journal's decision-making process rather than supporting the scientific community growth and exchange of knowledge (that reviewer comments should contribute to in the first place).
As a result of this unusual procedure, I will no longer be submitting or possibly writing reviews for this journal.
In this way, it appears that the editorial board of Scientia Iranica Journal is only using the reviewers' efforts to support the journal's decision-making process rather than supporting the scientific community growth and exchange of knowledge (that reviewer comments should contribute to in the first place).
As a result of this unusual procedure, I will no longer be submitting or possibly writing reviews for this journal.
23.0 weeks
23.0 weeks
n/a
3 reports
Rejected
2021
Motivation:
very long review process!