Reviews for "The Review of Symbolic Logic"

Journal title	Average duration			Review reports (1^st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page)	1^st rev. rnd	Tot. handling	Im. rejection	Number	Quality	Overall rating	Outcome
The Review of Symbolic Logic	29.0 weeks	29.0 weeks	n/a	2	2 (moderate)	2 (moderate)	Rejected
The Review of Symbolic Logic	Motivation: Reviewer 1 was clearly into my field, and gave me a "Revise and Resubmit" with some precious suggestions. As for Reviewer 2 instead, who suggested "Reject", s/he seemed not to be really into my field (or s/he seemed to follow a, say, competing school within the same field). S/he suggested me to take into account theories which have little or nothing to do with the one I investigated in my paper, and made some assertions without justifying them. Also, her/his observations went not beyond page 7 (over 32), which suggests that s/he made very little effort to understand the content of the paper (s/he said that some definitions were unclear, but in reality they were formulated in a way which is standard in the field).