Reviews for "Nature Biotechnology"
Journal title | Average duration | Review reports (1st review rnd.) |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(click to go to journal page) | 1st rev. rnd | Tot. handling | Im. rejection | Number | Quality | Overall rating | Outcome |
Nature Biotechnology | 4.4 weeks |
10.7 weeks |
n/a | 2 | 5 (excellent) |
5 (excellent) |
Accepted |
Motivation: The reviewer comments were practical and helpful. Overall, the review process improved the manuscript significantly and was very straightforward. | |||||||
Nature Biotechnology | n/a | n/a | 9.0 days |
n/a | n/a | n/a | Rejected (im.) |
Nature Biotechnology | Immediately accepted after 0.3 weeks | Accepted (im.) | |||||
Motivation: The content which I have presented in my manuscript seems to be novel and productive information. Hence, Nature biotechnology journal is exactly fitted for review. | |||||||
Nature Biotechnology | 17.4 weeks |
17.4 weeks |
n/a | 0 | n/a | 4 (very good) |
Accepted |
Motivation: They took a long time to answer, but the experience was positive. After accepting the article, it was quickly published (46 days). | |||||||
Nature Biotechnology | 6.9 weeks |
31.6 weeks |
n/a | 3 | 4 (very good) |
3 (good) |
Accepted |
Motivation: Initial submission was fine - took them a while until we heard back but not too bad. First round of reviews was fine too, criticisms were appropriately formulated. After revising, it took them quite a long time to give us an update which was the "fear period" it won't be accepted after all the effort (which it then did fortunately). |
|||||||
Nature Biotechnology | 23.1 weeks |
23.1 weeks |
n/a | 1 | 2 (moderate) |
0 (very bad) |
Rejected |
Motivation: After submission, it took about 6 weeks until the editor responded and sent the manuscript for external review. Then it took another 11 weeks until they got comments back from only one reviewer after we emailed the editor several times. This extremely slow handling of the manuscript is just irresponsible and lack of efficiency. | |||||||
Nature Biotechnology | n/a | n/a | 69.0 days |
n/a | n/a | n/a | Rejected (im.) |
Motivation: After 8 weeks of waiting, we started contacting them, and we still had to email and call them multiple times over the next couple weeks to get an answer. | |||||||
Nature Biotechnology | n/a | n/a | 10.0 days |
n/a | n/a | n/a | Rejected (im.) |
Nature Biotechnology | 11.7 weeks |
19.0 weeks |
n/a | 1 | 5 (excellent) |
4 (very good) |
Accepted |