Reviews for "Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical"
|Journal title||Average duration||Review reports
(1st review rnd.)
|(click to go to journal page)||1st rev. rnd||Tot. handling||Im. rejection||Number||Quality||Overall rating||Outcome|
|Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical||n/a||n/a||12.0
|Motivation: I did not expect that the reputable journal allows such careless and superficial reviews. As far as I understand, the Referee did not recommend the manuscript for a full review and further consideration because "the paper revisits the well-studied areas ..." and "there is nothing essentially new here ...". He/she didn't even try to understand the essence of our approach.|
|Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical||n/a||n/a||11.0