Reviews for "Journal of Comparative Germanic Linguistics"

Journal title Average duration Review reports
(1st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page) 1st rev. rnd Tot. handling Im. rejection Number Quality Overall rating Outcome
Journal of Comparative Germanic Linguistics 13.0
weeks
18.1
weeks
n/a 3 4
(very good)
5
(excellent)
Accepted
Motivation: Out of the 3 reviews I received, 2 were of specially high quality; both of the suggested revisions but the comments were reasonable and they made me realise where I didn't include enogh details of my analysis in the first version. The third review was quite problematic, though, as this person was evidently biased against the framework and repeatedly misquited both my research and that of others.
I highly appreciated the constructive way of handling from the editor, who also evidently took enougth time to read through the paper and make suggestions both during the revision process and during editing.
Journal of Comparative Germanic Linguistics 11.0
weeks
11.0
weeks
n/a 3 4
(very good)
4
(very good)
Rejected
Motivation: All reviewers have carefully studied the manuscript and gave valuable feedback. Their critique of my manuscript was fair and sound.