Reviews for "iScience"

Average duration			Review reports (1^st review rnd.)
1^st rev. rnd	Tot. handling	Im. rejection	Number	Quality	Overall rating	Outcome	Year
n/a	n/a	7.0 days	n/a	n/a	n/a	Rejected (im.)	2021
Motivation: We received a notification about rejecting the manuscript from the editor on April 5, due to the manuscript does not fit editorial criteria.
5.1 weeks	5.1 weeks	n/a	1	5 (excellent)	5 (excellent)	Accepted	2021
Motivation: Our manuscript was rejected at Cell Reports, due to a clearly unreasonable reviewer. The Cell Reports editor communicated with the iScience editor and encouraged us to send the manuscript there. We did so, and the iScience editor find one more reviewer to review our revisions (for the comments raised by the Cell Reports reviewers). It was accepted quickly
10.1 weeks	15.6 weeks	n/a	2	5 (excellent)	5 (excellent)	Accepted	2022
Motivation: Reviewers were nice and knowledgble but a bit slow. 10 weeks for first round, 5 weeks for second.
4.0 weeks	4.0 weeks	n/a	3	2 (moderate)	3 (good)	Drawn back	2020
5.0 weeks	5.1 weeks	n/a	4	3 (good)	3 (good)	Accepted	2020
Motivation: Detailed and highly demanding comments from reviewers.