Reviews for "International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology"
Journal title | Average duration | Review reports (1st review rnd.) |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(click to go to journal page) | 1st rev. rnd | Tot. handling | Im. rejection | Number | Quality | Overall rating | Outcome |
International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology | 7.0 weeks |
26.0 weeks |
n/a | 2 | 3 (good) |
1 (bad) |
Accepted |
Motivation: The nomenclature reviewer made us change the name of the bacteria 3 times. At each of the 4 review rounds the editor and the reviewers asked us new experiments/analysis. We all would have saved a lot of time and frustration if all the additional work was asked for at the first round of review. The editor and one of the reviewer confuse type-setting and reviewing. For exemple, the last round of review consisted in putting the abstract in one paragraph instead of two and putting one bacterial name in italic in a figure. | |||||||
International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology | 17.4 weeks |
23.1 weeks |
n/a | 2 | 4 (very good) |
2 (moderate) |
Accepted |
Motivation: The reviewers were a bit harsh but fair. The editorial process was terribly long and frustrating. |