Dur. 1st rev. rnd
Tot. handling time
Imm. rejection time
Num. rev. reports
Report quality
Overall rating
Outcome
33.9 weeks
44.0 weeks
n/a
3 reports
4.0 / 5.0
0.0 / 5.0
Rejected
Motivation:
The first review round took about eight months and resulted in a major revision. We substantially revised the manuscript, adding a second data set and additional analyses, within the one-month deadline. At the revision stage we were also required to reformat the entire manuscript to the journal's style, including a non-standard reference format and retyping all equations in MathType, which took several days.
The second round took a further two months. Two of the three original reviewers recommended acceptance, and the editor added a new reviewer who had not seen the original version of the manuscript. The final recommendations were split 2-2, and the manuscript was rejected rather than given a further revision, even though several of the issues raised were correctable reporting errors in tables.
The quality of the reports was mixed. One second-round report was detailed and technically careful, while others were brief. Overall, the process took almost a year! Authors should be prepared for long waiting times and for new reviewers being added at later rounds. Format-free submission until acceptance would make the process much less burdensome for authors.
The second round took a further two months. Two of the three original reviewers recommended acceptance, and the editor added a new reviewer who had not seen the original version of the manuscript. The final recommendations were split 2-2, and the manuscript was rejected rather than given a further revision, even though several of the issues raised were correctable reporting errors in tables.
The quality of the reports was mixed. One second-round report was detailed and technically careful, while others were brief. Overall, the process took almost a year! Authors should be prepared for long waiting times and for new reviewers being added at later rounds. Format-free submission until acceptance would make the process much less burdensome for authors.