Dur. 1st rev. rnd
Tot. handling time
Imm. rejection time
Num. rev. reports
Report quality
Overall rating
Outcome
36.1 weeks
36.1 weeks
n/a
7 reports
4.0 / 5.0
0.0 / 5.0
Rejected
Motivation: My experience with Humanities and Social Sciences Communications raised concerns about the timeliness of the editorial process, communication, and the consistency of the final decision.

My manuscript went through multiple rounds of peer review and substantial revision. During the process, I experienced considerable delays and difficulties obtaining timely and clear information about the manuscript's status from the editorial office.

The final-round reviewer reports reflected different assessments. One reviewer explicitly recommended Minor Revision, describing the revised manuscript as substantially improved and close to being publishable, with only a few minor clarifications remaining. A second reviewer acknowledged the authors' efforts in addressing the previous comments. A third reviewer raised substantive concerns, but the report did not include an explicit recommendation for rejection.

The handling editor nevertheless rejected the manuscript, stating that substantial further work was required. A central concern with this decision is that it placed considerable emphasis on additional analyses that were not part of the manuscript's stated research objectives. In my view, the manuscript should have been assessed primarily against its declared research question and methodological framework. Requiring analyses addressing a substantially different or expanded research objective, particularly as a decisive reason for rejection at the final stage, raises questions about the consistency of the evaluation criteria.

I recognize that editors are entitled to make independent decisions and are not required to follow reviewers' recommendations. My concern is not the rejection itself, but the relationship between the reviewers' assessments, the revisions undertaken, and the grounds ultimately cited for rejection.

Importantly, I submitted a formal complaint to Springer Nature before the rejection decision was issued. The publisher subsequently informed me that the complaint had been escalated to senior editorial management for further examination.

Overall, my experience involved substantial delays, difficulties in editorial communication, and concerns about the alignment between the manuscript's stated objectives and the criteria applied in the final decision. I believe these aspects warrant attention when assessing the transparency and consistency of the journal's editorial process.
Drawn back before first editorial decision after 112.0 days
Drawn back
Motivation: Almost 4 months under editor assessment, before sending the manuscript out for peer review. I've tried to contact the Editorial Office twice, asking about the status of the manuscript, but received no response.
Drawn back before first editorial decision after 72.0 days
Drawn back
Motivation: After submitted my manuscript to HSSC I receiving no updates. I followed up with the journal after 62 days to inquire about the status. In their response, they explained that they were facing significant difficulties securing a handling editor and had not yet found the right person to take on the paper. They noted that their editorial board consists of a voluntary external panel, meaning members have the autonomy to decline manuscript assignments. This made the situation clear: the bottleneck was not a lack of peer reviewers, but a more fundamental issue at an earlier stage. The process was entirely stalled at the internal editor-assignment level before peer review could even begin. Because the submission was stuck at this preliminary phase with no resolution in sight, I withdrew my manuscript and have since submitted it to another journal.
8.7 weeks
17.3 weeks
n/a
3 reports
4.0 / 5.0
0.0 / 5.0
Rejected
Motivation: The journal appears overly fixated on certain formalistic requirements. For instance, during the review process, they demanded raw data and insisted that IRB approval dates must precede data collection. While rigor is certainly commendable, excessive formalism becomes counterproductive—especially when the editorial team disregards researchers' explanations, wasting everyone's time. In fact, our study did not involve any physical or psychological impact on participants; it was merely a social survey on certain attitudes, which arguably did not require IRB approval at all. Ironically, our commitment to rigor—providing the IRB approval number—ended up becoming the very reason for rejection.
n/a
n/a
33 days
n/a
n/a
n/a
Rejected (im.)
Motivation: This journal requires strict initial quality check such as ethical approvals and informed consent.
The editorial staff are responsive and email replies are prompt.