Reviews for "Heredity"

Journal title Average duration Review reports
(1st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page) 1st rev. rnd Tot. handling Im. rejection Number Quality Overall rating Outcome
Heredity 10.0
weeks
10.0
weeks
n/a 2 3
(good)
3
(good)
Rejected
Motivation: Great comments from only one reviewer
Too much time for taken for all process
Heredity 6.4
weeks
6.4
weeks
n/a 3 2
(moderate)
3
(good)
Rejected
Motivation: Three reviewers judged very differently about the manuscript, one suggested minor changes and made valueable comments, one was intermediate, suggested major revisions, but from the report it appears that this was not a specialist in the field, the third referee recommended rejection, although there was only one major point that was criticized. We wrote a rebuttal to the points raised by the referees and asked for a resubmission, which was allowed, although the initial rejection. We then re-worked the manuscript including many new analyses.
Heredity 6.9
weeks
6.9
weeks
n/a 3 3
(good)
3
(good)
Rejected