Reviews for "Environmental Modelling and Software"

Journal title Average duration Review reports
(1st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page) 1st rev. rnd Tot. handling Im. rejection Number Quality Overall rating Outcome
Environmental Modelling and Software 47.7
weeks
60.8
weeks
n/a 2 2
(moderate)
2
(moderate)
Accepted
Environmental Modelling and Software 17.4
weeks
17.4
weeks
n/a 2 1
(bad)
3
(good)
Rejected
Motivation: The journal is fast, and the editors are very responsible, however, the quality of reviewer's comments are low and biased. One reviewer clearly neither has a good understanding of the methodology nor carefully read the manuscript, given 1) give comments that are theoretically incorrect on the model; 2) point out a limitation that has already been properly dealt with as a major problem. In conclusion, as a top-tier journal, the experience is really disappointing.
Environmental Modelling and Software 35.7
weeks
35.7
weeks
n/a 2 5
(excellent)
3
(good)
Accepted
Motivation: The quality of the reviews was excellent, increasing the manuscript quality a lot. However the overall review process was too long.
Environmental Modelling and Software n/a n/a 44.0
days
n/a n/a n/a Rejected (im.)
Motivation: Although the paper presented a systemic modelling work with R-programmed Morris sensitivity analysis that could be useful for other models, the decision was "your paper is a bit too narrowly focused and hence doesn't fit within the scope of the journal".
Such a decision came after 1.5 months, which is quite long given that no further constructive comment was provided.
Environmental Modelling and Software n/a n/a 4.0
days
n/a n/a n/a Rejected (im.)
Environmental Modelling and Software n/a n/a 54.0
days
n/a n/a n/a Rejected (im.)
Motivation: The first internal review was a bit long (almost 2 months) given the output (rejection without external review). However, elements were provided in order to improve the paper quality.
Environmental Modelling and Software 13.0
weeks
15.0
weeks
n/a 5 5
(excellent)
4
(very good)
Accepted
Environmental Modelling and Software 25.1
weeks
25.3
weeks
n/a 3 3
(good)
3
(good)
Accepted
Environmental Modelling and Software 12.0
weeks
12.0
weeks
n/a 3 4
(very good)
3
(good)
Rejected