Reviews for "Ecology and Society"

Journal title	Average duration			Review reports (1^st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page)	1^st rev. rnd	Tot. handling	Im. rejection	Number	Quality	Overall rating	Outcome
Ecology and Society	31.4 weeks	47.0 weeks	n/a	2	4 (very good)	1 (bad)	Accepted
Ecology and Society	Motivation: The review process was quite slow, with 7 months for the first round of reviews and 3.5 months for the revisions. Given that the revisions weren't even sent out to reviewers, they were just sitting on his/her desk that whole time! The redeeming qualities were the managing editor, who was helpful, responsive, and sympathetic to the delays; and one of the two reviewers, which was insightful and improved the manuscript. I enjoy reading this journal, but likely will try to avoid publishing there again (at least until after I get tenure) due to the extremely slow turnaround time.
Ecology and Society	n/a	n/a	6.0 days	n/a	n/a	n/a	Rejected (im.)
Ecology and Society	Motivation: Provided 3 alternative journals name but did not say why exactly why it did not.
Ecology and Society	n/a	n/a	12.0 days	n/a	n/a	n/a	Rejected (im.)
Ecology and Society	Motivation: I understand the issue of fit and appreciated the speedy rejection.
Ecology and Society	26.0 weeks	69.4 weeks	n/a	2	4 (very good)	0 (very bad)	Rejected