Reviews for "Ecology and Society"
Journal title | Average duration | Review reports (1st review rnd.) |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(click to go to journal page) | 1st rev. rnd | Tot. handling | Im. rejection | Number | Quality | Overall rating | Outcome |
Ecology and Society | 31.4 weeks |
47.0 weeks |
n/a | 2 | 4 (very good) |
1 (bad) |
Accepted |
Motivation: The review process was quite slow, with 7 months for the first round of reviews and 3.5 months for the revisions. Given that the revisions weren't even sent out to reviewers, they were just sitting on his/her desk that whole time! The redeeming qualities were the managing editor, who was helpful, responsive, and sympathetic to the delays; and one of the two reviewers, which was insightful and improved the manuscript. I enjoy reading this journal, but likely will try to avoid publishing there again (at least until after I get tenure) due to the extremely slow turnaround time. |
|||||||
Ecology and Society | n/a | n/a | 6.0 days |
n/a | n/a | n/a | Rejected (im.) |
Motivation: Provided 3 alternative journals name but did not say why exactly why it did not. | |||||||
Ecology and Society | n/a | n/a | 12.0 days |
n/a | n/a | n/a | Rejected (im.) |
Motivation: I understand the issue of fit and appreciated the speedy rejection. | |||||||
Ecology and Society | 26.0 weeks |
69.4 weeks |
n/a | 2 | 4 (very good) |
0 (very bad) |
Rejected |