Dur. 1st rev. rnd
Tot. handling time
Imm. rejection time
Num. rev. reports
Report quality
Overall rating
Outcome
Year
63.6 weeks
63.6 weeks
n/a
9 reports
Rejected
2025
Motivation:
The journal took 15 months and went through 4 rounds of external review, only to ultimately reject the manuscript. It was an incredible waste of time. After three rounds of major revisions, all reviewers agreed the paper was ready for publication—except for one reviewer. He rejected it twice, and on the third round, claimed that his expectations had now increased, bringing up completely new concerns that had never been mentioned before. This is utterly unreasonable. I strongly discourage anyone from submitting to this journal. Four rounds of review is an unacceptable burden and a form of academic exhaustion.
10.4 weeks
33.7 weeks
n/a
2 reports
Rejected
2020
Motivation:
At first, the manuscript received two positive reviewer reports asking for revision. In the second round, one reviewer suggested minor revisions while the other said that even though the paper was strengthened it still needed more work. In the third report, a new reviewer was introduced whose report was also in a positive tone asking for revisions. The fourth time, I have only received one reviewer report from a new reviewer who briefly stated that the manuscript was not adequate for the journal (stating that the sampling was too limited and arguing that the manuscript was not a good fit for the journal).
Complete waste of my time and the time of previous reviewers since all of their reports were positive. The new reviewer (Reviewer 5 as it has been named by the journal) was also pretty rude and the report was not constructive at all, lacking any kind of suggestions. I have lost 9 months with this journal and it was the worst experience I ever had with a journal. I strongly recommend everyone to stay away.
Complete waste of my time and the time of previous reviewers since all of their reports were positive. The new reviewer (Reviewer 5 as it has been named by the journal) was also pretty rude and the report was not constructive at all, lacking any kind of suggestions. I have lost 9 months with this journal and it was the worst experience I ever had with a journal. I strongly recommend everyone to stay away.