Reviews for "Climatic Change"

Journal title	Average duration			Review reports (1^st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page)	1^st rev. rnd	Tot. handling	Im. rejection	Number	Quality	Overall rating	Outcome
Climatic Change	13.6 weeks	13.6 weeks	n/a	2	3 (good)	4 (very good)	Rejected
Climatic Change	Motivation: One of the referees was constructive, but the other was not. I think we could answer to the questions&comments of this critical reviewer, however the editors didn't offered an opportunity for revision.
Climatic Change	35.1 weeks	43.4 weeks	n/a	3	4 (very good)	3 (good)	Accepted
Climatic Change	Motivation: Actually, we initially submitted this as a comment to an article previously published in the same journal, so there was a review prior to the first review shown here. We were generally pleased with the reviewers' comments and with higher level editors responsiveness. However, the reviews and the editorial handling of the reviews took too long. We had to repeatedly ask for updates.
Climatic Change	16.0 weeks	23.9 weeks	n/a	2	4 (very good)	4 (very good)	Accepted
Climatic Change	Motivation: The first round of review was a bit slow because there was a mix-up in the system and the manuscript was wrongly marked as being in pre-production for the first few weeks after initial submission. This was rectified after upon contacting the editor after 4 weeks had elapsed. From that point on, the rest of the process was satisfactory and hitch-free.
Climatic Change	n/a	n/a	2.0 days	n/a	n/a	n/a	Rejected (im.)
Climatic Change	Motivation: Transparent, fast and comprehensible decision. Would definitely submit there again.
Climatic Change	34.7 weeks	69.4 weeks	n/a	2	1 (bad)	1 (bad)	Accepted
Climatic Change	Motivation: The review required too much time!
Climatic Change	25.7 weeks	38.7 weeks	n/a	2	4 (very good)	4 (very good)	Accepted
Climatic Change	Motivation: Fairly good review process, with acceptable time between submission and acceptance.
Climatic Change	n/a	n/a	41.0 days	n/a	n/a	n/a	Rejected (im.)
Climatic Change	21.9 weeks	21.9 weeks	n/a	2	4 (very good)	3 (good)	Rejected
Climatic Change	16.4 weeks	16.4 weeks	n/a	2	3 (good)	3 (good)	Rejected