Reviews for "Climate Research"
Journal title | Average duration | Review reports (1st review rnd.) |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(click to go to journal page) | 1st rev. rnd | Tot. handling | Im. rejection | Number | Quality | Overall rating | Outcome |
Climate Research | 13.0 weeks |
21.7 weeks |
n/a | 3 | 3 (good) |
2 (moderate) |
Accepted |
Motivation: The reviewing time could have been shorter. One of the reviewer was clearly not well-acquainted with my area of research, hence very bad review. Meanwhile the other reviewers provided very constructive feedback. |
|||||||
Climate Research | 12.0 weeks |
16.0 weeks |
n/a | 3 | 4 (very good) |
4 (very good) |
Accepted |
Climate Research | 6.6 weeks |
14.7 weeks |
n/a | 2 | 3 (good) |
4 (very good) |
Accepted |
Motivation: Good process. Efficient and clear. | |||||||
Climate Research | 7.6 weeks |
7.9 weeks |
n/a | 4 | 4 (very good) |
5 (excellent) |
Accepted |
Motivation: Very quick but thorough review process Many reviewers (5 in our case), who's comments can improve the paper |