Reviews for "Automatica"

Review this journal Show journal page
Journal title Average duration Review reports
(1st review rnd.)
(click to go to journal page) 1st rev. rnd Tot. handling Im. rejection Number Quality Overall rating Outcome
Automatica 17.4
weeks		 17.4
weeks		 n/a 4 3
(good)		 4
(very good)		 Rejected
Automatica 13.0
weeks		 27.0
weeks		 n/a 2 5
(excellent)		 5
(excellent)		 Accepted
Automatica 26.0
weeks		 39.1
weeks		 n/a 4 3
(good)		 4
(very good)		 Accepted
Automatica 21.7
weeks		 21.7
weeks		 n/a 3 5
(excellent)		 5
(excellent)		 Accepted
Automatica 26.0
weeks		 39.1
weeks		 n/a 4 4
(very good)		 4
(very good)		 Accepted
Automatica 39.1
weeks		 60.8
weeks		 n/a 3 4
(very good)		 0
(very bad)		 Rejected
Motivation: The decision to reject on the basis of being out of scope for the journal needs to be made immediately, not after sixteen months in process.
Automatica 6.9
weeks		 6.9
weeks		 n/a 2 5
(excellent)		 3
(good)		 Rejected
Motivation: The reviewers found a subtle but serious flaw in the mathematics. The flaw was fixable, so I regret the reject/no resubmission decision, but it was handled fairly.