Reviews for "Applied Soil Ecology"

Average duration			Review reports (1^st review rnd.)
1^st rev. rnd	Tot. handling	Im. rejection	Number	Quality	Overall rating	Outcome	Year
16.6 weeks	22.6 weeks	n/a	2	4 (very good)	3 (good)	Accepted	2019
Motivation: The editor was not very responsive. The manuscript state stayed at "Decision in progress" for weeks. Also, it took weeks before the manuscript was sent to reviewers (even regarding the revised manuscript).
14.3 weeks	14.3 weeks	n/a	2	5 (excellent)	5 (excellent)	Drawn back	2017
Motivation: Review process was relatively fast, very thorough and high quality comments were given by reviewers. After about 3 months we asked editor when can we expect the first decision, and editor responded very quickly and we got the decision in next week.